Colin Neilson

Colin Neilson

Year of Call: 2022

Colin called to the Bar in 2022. Prior to calling he had 10 years’ experience in criminal work including private practice as a criminal defence solicitor followed by a period as a Procurator Fiscal Depute.

He has appeared regularly in the High Court of Justiciary, the Court of Criminal Appeal, the Sheriff Appeal Court and Sheriff Courts all over Scotland. He has extensive experience in the defence and prosecution of violent, sexual, dishonesty and drug-related offences. His interests lie on all areas of criminal law. He is a highly motivated and diligent court practitioner. He is very popular with instructing agents.

Areas of Practice

Testimonials

“Colin is punctual, prepared and professional. He has an assured and assertive manner in consultation giving clear unequivocal advice. In trial he has great experience as a fiscal depute and is able and unflappable in a court room setting.”

“An extremely safe pair of hands and highly recommended”

“Colin’s combination of thoroughness and clarity is a real asset in the appeal court”.

Appointments & Memberships

  • Ad-Hoc Advocate Depute in Criminal Trials
  • Legal member of the Mental Health Tribunal for Scotland

Publications

  • Faculty of Advocates Consultation Response on the Bail and Release from Custody (Scotland) Bill, 2022

Selected Cases

JH v HMA [2024] HCJAC 10 – Appeal against conviction on the basis of misdirection.

Murdoch v PF, Perth [2024] SAC (Crim) 1 – Appeal challenging a dog destruction order.

Stuart Birtley v HMA 2022 – Successful appeal against a 14 month prison sentence resulting in a Community Payback Order being imposed.

Sean O’Brien v HMA 2023 – Successful appeal against a 43 month prison sentence resulting in the imposition of a reduced period of imprisonment.

HMA v SC 2024 – Acquittal in a rape trial.

HMA v AR 2024 – Acquittal in a historic sexual offences trial.

©2025 Black Chambers. Webmaster Faculty Services Ltd. Registered in Scotland No 48261.

The use of your information

Black Chambers is fully compliant with the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) – a regulation in EU law on data protection and privacy for all individuals within the European Union.
We take your privacy seriously and will only use your details to administer your enquiry with us. For more information on our Privacy Policy, please visit blackchambers.co.uk/privacy-policy/.